Six people shown in colourful portrait panels, representing the importance of human roles in AI organisational design.

As AI Changes Work, What Human Roles Should We Protect?

Read Time: 4 mins

Organisations are investing in artificial intelligence (AI) to improve productivity, reduce costs and change how work gets done. For many, this means rethinking their operating models. Tasks that once required people can now be completed by AI. Some roles may change. Others will disappear.

There are significant benefits to this new technology. It offers us opportunities to improve services, reduce repetitive work and help our organisations achieve more with their resources. But as we calculate the financial benefits of AI, I wonder whether we’re giving enough thought to two questions.

What human roles do we want to retain in our organisations? And what responsibility do we have towards the people whose jobs disappear?

I think both questions are important to consider before organisations rethink their future operating models and decide on AI investments.

When efficiency becomes the main measure

Think about an organisation introducing AI across several business functions. Each AI investment has its own business case. One reduces administrative roles. Another automates customer service. A third reduces the number of employees needed to analyse information or prepare reports. Individually, these investments may make good commercial sense.

But what happens when we consider their combined impact? Over time, an organisation could remove significant numbers of human roles without having made a deliberate decision about the kind of organisation it wants to become. It may also lose experience, relationships and opportunities for people to develop their careers.

There is another concern. We have often assumed that people displaced by technology will eventually find work elsewhere. Previous waves of technological change have created new types of employment. AI may be different. If organisations across an industry are replacing similar roles at the same time, finding another job may become much harder. We don’t yet know how this will unfold, but I don’t think organisations should assume that the labour market will absorb everyone whose job disappears.

1. Deliberately protect human roles in organisational design

As AI becomes more capable, organisations will face an important question. Just because technology can perform a role, does that mean we should replace the person doing it? What sort of organisations do we want to create in an AI-enabled future?

Rather than starting with which roles AI can replace, perhaps we should also ask which roles we want people to continue performing. This isn’t about preserving every existing job. Roles will change, and AI can support people in doing their work. It’s about making conscious decisions about where humans should remain within the future operating model.

Preserve meaningful human judgement. Where do we want people to retain genuine responsibility for decisions? Human oversight should involve more than simply approving an AI recommendation. People need the authority and understanding to question, challenge and make decisions.

Retain human care and connection. People need other people. In healthcare, education, leadership and other areas involving personal relationships, being understood and cared for by another person has value in itself. We should be careful not to lose that human element in pursuit of efficiency.

Consider the commercial value of human relationships. Think about salespeople and account managers. Their role isn’t simply to complete transactions. They build trust, understand their clients and develop relationships over time. If organisations replace these roles with AI, they may reduce costs while weakening the relationships that support customer loyalty and future revenue.

Protect opportunities to develop future employees. If AI takes over entry-level and intermediate work, how will people gain the experience needed to become tomorrow’s specialists, managers and leaders? We need to think about career pathways, not just the roles required today.

Look at the combined impact of AI investments. Rather than assessing each change in isolation, organisations should take a portfolio view of change. This means considering how new systems, tools and processes interact, alongside the impact on people.

The aim is not to keep people doing work that technology could make easier. It’s to ensure we retain meaningful human roles, relationships and judgement within organisations as technology changes what is possible.

2. Build employee transitions into AI business cases

The second question is what happens to people whose roles are no longer needed. Most organisations have established processes for managing redundancies. These may include redundancy payments, notice periods and outplacement services. But what if the employee’s role is disappearing across an entire industry? Traditional outplacement support may be of limited value if there are fewer similar jobs to apply for.

If an AI investment is expected to deliver financial savings through workforce reductions, the business case should also include the cost of helping affected employees prepare for what comes next. The support required will depend on the roles affected and the opportunities for employees to retrain or develop skills for work in other fields.

It could include funded retraining in a different field, supported opportunities to develop new skills in parallel with existing work, or moving into different roles within the organisation. Financial support for retraining, for example, could help someone gain qualifications in a field where there is stronger demand.

There’s no simple formula for determining how much funding should be allocated to employee transition support within an AI business case. The cost will depend on the number of roles affected, the skills required and the opportunities for employees to move into different types of work. If workforce reductions form part of the financial benefits of an AI investment, the cost of supporting those employees through the transition should form part of the business case.

There should also be accountability for delivering that support. In major transformation programs, organisations commonly appoint benefit owners who are accountable for achieving the expected benefits. If someone is accountable for delivering the financial savings, a people benefits owner should be accountable for both the workforce reductions and the support provided to those employees.

This doesn’t mean guaranteeing everyone another job. Organisations cannot control the wider employment market. But they can take responsibility for the commitments they make to people whose work is being replaced. They can also track what happens, learn from the experience and use that knowledge to inform future AI investments.

The organisations we choose to create

Recent research is increasingly focused on the need to redesign work rather than simply remove roles. McKinsey’s October 2026 article on AI and organisational design explores how AI is changing the way organisations structure teams, allocate work and develop employees. Similarly, Harvard Business Review has argued for redesigning work, not cutting roles.

What discussions are you having internally in your organisation? As AI becomes more capable, we may increasingly face decisions about retaining people in roles that technology could perform. Those decisions shouldn’t be based on efficiency alone. Human relationships, connection, judgement and the opportunity to develop through work all contribute to the organisations and societies we create. Some of these human qualities have direct commercial value that may be difficult to capture in a business case.

We need to decide now what technology will do, which human roles we want to retain and how we will support people whose roles disappear. These are choices worth making deliberately, before they are made for us through a series of individual investment decisions.

Let’s Talk

Skill and Will take the time to understand what you want from coaching and discuss the approach that best fits your needs

Call Now or Enquire

Name